The Energy Content of U.S. Exports and Imports
K.7 (#724 in RFD Series)
_ - -INTERNATIONAL FINANCE DISCUSSION PAPERS ~~
~ THE ENERGY CONTENT OF U.S. EXPORTS AND IMPORTS ~
~ Norman S. Fieleke
Discussion Paper No. 51, August 19, 1974
' Division of International Finance
Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System
The analysis and conclusions of this paper represent the views of the author and should not be interpreted as reflecting the views of the Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve
System or its staff. Discussion Papers in many cases are circulated in preliminary form to stimulate discussion and
comment and are not to be cited or quoted without the permission of the author.
The Energy Content of U.S. Exports and Imports
by Norman Ss. Fieleke*
Introduction -~ -
een
The recent oil crisis forcefully brought home the fact that the United States is a net importer of crude petroleum on a substantial scale. Because petroleum is an important energy sources the oil crisis immediately became an energy crisis. But crude petroleum is only one of the forms in which energy_is exported and imported; éoal and natural gas are other
obvious examples. In -addition, such natural forms are embodied in other
traded products3 for exampte, if a nation imported crude petroleum,
refined it, and exported the refined product, it would be absurd to count
1/
the nation's imports of crude petroleum as its total trade in energy. Input-out put analysis makes it possible to estimate the total amount of energy from coal, crude petroleum, natural gaS> hydropower s nuclear power, and geothermal power which is embodied in U.S. exports and competitive imports. The approach adopted in this study is to compute the
quantity of energy required from these “primary” energy sources both ooo esis
* The author is Assistant Adviser; Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System. He is indebted to staff of the Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) >» especially Norman Saunders and Charles Bowman, for advice and assistance in performing the computations underlying this study. Also, the technique used in the study resembles that in Wassily Leontief's classic “Domestic Production and Foreign Trade: The American Capital
Position Re-examined,” Proceedings of the American Philosophical Societys 97 (September, 1953), 332-48. However, the author assumes full responsi-~
pility for the views expressed in this paper.
1/ It is recognized that petroleum is imported not only for its energy content but also for other reasons. For purposes of this: study, this dis~ tinction is ignored, gince consumption of petroleum (and coal, etc.) for whatever reason ig tantamount to consumption of energy.
22° (1) to produce 4 million dollars’ worth of U.S. exports and (2) to replace from domestic production a million dollars’ worth of competitive imports. Both. exports and imports are of average 1970 composition, the latest yeat for which the necessary input-output data are available. Thus, the study provides 4 rough calculation of the extent to which the United States was a net exporter OT. net importer of energy per million dollars of balanced
trade in 1970, provided competitive {imports are produced abroad with
techniques that do not differ greatly from the techniques used to produce
substitutes in this country, 4 ‘and provided the energy intensity of the relatively small volume of_ noncompetitive , imports. is not vastly different from the energy intensity of competitive imports. The results are examined both including and excluding direct exports and imports of crude petroleum, coal, and natural gas, because trade in these primary encrsy sources has changed dramatically since 1970 and because the main purpose of the study 4s to appraise the energy embodied in other traded products.
” Aside from sheer curiosity, there are several reasons why it is of interest to know the energy content of a million dollars’ worth of balanced trade. First, the more energy-intensive are U.S. imports relative to U.S. exports, then, other things being equal, (1) the greater is the real burden imposed on the United States by the increase in the relative
price of energy» and (2) the greater will be the deterioration in the U.S.
balance of trade. Second, if the United States were a net importer of
energy exe Luding direct net im ports of crude petroleum, it would be a net
importer of energy from the non-oi l-exporting countries as a group, so
RT RTS
pte
-3-
that the U.S. terms of trade and balance of trade would tend to deteriorate (ceteris paribus) with those-countries as well as with the oil-exporting countries as a result of the increase in the relative price of energy. Finally, we can compute the net exports or imports of energy for each industrial classification and rank the classifications in order of their
net energy imports, so as to obtain some idea of the relative importance
of each classification as an exporter or importer of embodied energy.
Methodology 7 —
~—
The first step in carrying out the. study was to cowpute the value of exports of goods and services by industry class per milfion dollars of total 1970 exports, and to make a similar computation for competitive imports, i.e., for imports for which domestically produced substitutes are represented in the input-output tables constructed by the Commerce Department
. oo _
2/ Conceptually, there is very little difference between exports and imports as reported in the balance-of-payments statistics and exports and imports as used by BLS in the input-output computations underlying this study, except that noncompetitive imports and other items (such as income flows) which could not be classified in terms of the U.S. input-output sectors are excluded from this study. Also, in this study neither exports nor imports include reexports of foreign merchandise. Both exports and imports are valued at the U.S. port of export or import. The value of imports thus includes duties as well as transportation and insurance from the foreign port. With respect to exports, because the excess of the port value over "producers'” value is accounted for by the ‘margin’ industries (wholesale trade, etc.), the energy required by each margin industry was computed separately and then allocated as appropriate to the other producing industries to obtain the total energy requirement corresponding to the port value of each of the latter industries’ output. The total value of exports included in this study is $51,835 million, and the total value of imports is $47,743 million.
It should be noted that the composition of U.S. trade in 1970 was no doubt somewhat different from the equilibrium composition, since, among other things, exchange rates were not in equilibrium, a fact which is significant because some items are more price- (or exchange-rate-~) elastic than others.
~4he
The figures so derived for each industry class were then multiplied by the
class's input-output coefficients for (1) crude petroleum, (2) natural gas»
(3) coal, and (4) “other primary energy sources (hydropower, nuclear power, and geothermal power), where the coefficients were expressed as dollar requirements (direct and indirect) per dollar of delivery to final demand in 1970.2! ‘The resulting data showed the dollar value of crude
petroleum, natural gas; coal, and “other” energy gources required, by a
industry class, per million dollars of total U.S. exports and competitive import replacements. These data were then divided by the appropriate unit values to yield requirements of petroleum in terms of barrels, of natural gas in cubic feet, of coal in tons, and of Vother" energy sources in kilowatt hours «“! Finally, these Vreal" energy requirements data were
converted into the comon denominator of prU-equivalents =! ———— .
3/ For each industry class, the input-output data provide a coefficient for crude petroleum and natural gas combined; they do not provide 4 coefficient for crude petroleum alone and another for natural gas alone. In consultation_with BLS staff, the coefficients for crude petroleum and natural gas were assumed to be 90 percent and 10 percent, respectively, of the coefficients for crude petroleum and natural gas combined, since the total output of crude petroleum and natural gas in 1970 by value was 90 percent crude petroleum and 10 percent natural gas. Similarly, for each industry class the coefficient for “other" primary energy sources was assumed to be 15 percent of the coefficient for electric utilities, since 15 percent of the value of electricity delivered to final demand was Pron duced by hydro, nuclear, and geothermal installations.
4/ The procedure described was not followed in the case of direct imports and exports of coal, crude petroleum, and natural gas, partly because the unit values appropriate for domestic production were not appropriate for deriving the volumes of direct trade in these items. Instead, the actual ‘yolumes per million dollars of exports and imports were enteréd directly.
5/ The following conversion factors were employed: 5,620,900 BIUs per barrel of crude petroleum; 1,031 BTUs per cubic foot of natural gas; 24,220,000 BTUs per ton of coal; and 10,494 BTUs per kilowatt hour. See U.S. Department of the Interior, Bureau of Mines, Mineral Industr Surveys: Weekly Coal Report No. 2943, February 8, 1974, P- 3-
Results _ The results are summarized in Table i, and detail by industry class is presented in Table 2. The main contribution of this paper is to estimate the extent to which the United States imports or exports energy which is present in the ‘primary’ energy sources that in turn are embodied in other goods. Table 1 indicates that, in terms of the definitions used in this study, the United States is a net importer of energy in forms other than the primary sources to the extent of nearly 18 billion BTUs for each million dollars' worth of balanced trade of average 1970 composition; this figure includes 11 billion BTUs derived from crude petroleum. (To put some perspective on these numbers, if an automobile obtains 15 miles per gallon of gasoline, the volume of gasoline which contains 1 billion BTUs is adequate to propel the automobile a distance of about 120,000 miles.©! ) If direct trade in crude petroleum, natural gas, and coal is included, the table of course shows a much greater net import position, amounting to nearly 74 billion BTUs, although there is a slim net export position, amounting to 859 million BTUs, if direct trade in crude petroleum is excluded. | Table 2 shows that by industry class, and excluding direct trade in primary energy sources, the largest net imports of energy per million dollars of balanced 1970 trade occur in petroleum products, followed by blast furnaces and basic steel products, by motor vehicles, and by paper “6/ There are 5,240,000 BTUs per 42 gallon barrel of gasoline; see U.S. Department of the Interior, loc. cit. Technically, a British thermal unit
is defined as the amount of heat required to raise the temperature of one pound of water 1 degree Fahrenheit at or near its maximum density.
-6-
Table 1
— Energy Requirements in BTUs per Million Dollars _ | of Total U.S. Exports and Import Replacements, 1970
(In millions of
Energy content of direct imports and ; exports of me - primary energy
BTU. requirements from:
Crude petroleum Exports —_ Imports ~
Net (exports +
Natural gas Exports ~ Imports Net (exports +)
Coal Exports Imports - Net (exports +)
Other sourcest! — . _ Exports Imports Net (exports +)
All sources except direct imports and exports of crude petroleum Exports Imports Net (exports +)
All above sources Exports Imports Net (exports +)
BTUs)
sources
541 74,950
274,409 -
1,824 16,774 -14,950
33,501 7
33,494,
35,325 16,781 18,544
35,866 91,731 -55,865
Energy
and
~ 28,651 39,437 7 =10,786
3,076 4,234
-1,158 —
15,038 20,572 ~=5,534
- 1,588 1,797 -209
48,354 66,040 -17, 686
48,354 66,040 -17 , 686
requirements for other imports
exports
Total
29,193 114,338 -85,195
4,900 21, 008 -16,108
48,539 20,579 27,960
1,588 1,797 -209
83,679 82,820 859
84,220 157,771 73,551
—_ _ ~
1/ Hydropower, nuclear power, and geothermal power.
Note: Source:
Detail may not add to totals because of rounding. See Table 2 and explanation in the text.
-7-
products, in that order. The Aargest wet exports, in order of magnitude,
eccur_in crops and other agricultural products, chemical products, plastic
materials and synthetic rubber, and air transportation.
Conclusions
It is well known that the United States is a net importer of crude petroleum. This study presents 4 finding that is much. more significant for purposes of analyzing the effects on the nation of a vise in the price of energy: This finding is that U.S. imports as a whole seem to be considerably more energy-intensive than U.S. exports. ~ This discovery makes much more defensible the hypothesis that higher energy prices tend to worsen both the terms and the balance of trade of the United States.
The study also suggests that 4£ direct trade in crude petroleum Zs ignored, but all other trade is counted, U.S. exports tend to be slightly more energy-intensive than U.S. imports. Since the United States has substantial exports to the countries from which it imports crude petroleum, the magnitude of the 1970 U.S. energy deficit with those countries was less than is indicated by the energy component of direct crude petroleum imports; and, correspondingly, the slim energy surplus on trade excluding direct crude petroleum imports no doubt implies an energy deficit on trade with the non-oil-exporting countries. Thus the
U.S. terms of trade and balance of trade with these latter countries, as
Sree]
(2 Be
well as with the oil-exporting countries, are probably adversely affected (ceteris paribus) by the increased cost of energy «_!
-- Of course, a rise in the relative price of-energy-—has other implications for U.S. trade. For example, if the United States has a comparative advantage in the production of energy~saving capital goods, the nation's trade balance with other energy- importing countries will tend to improve
on that score. However, such considerations are beyond: the scope of this
study.
oe 7/ In this connection, it should be noted that the effects of a nondiscr:minatory increase in the relative price of energy on the U.S. terms and balance of trade with various areas would differ from the effects of discrimination in the foreign-supply of a primary energy source such as
crude petroleum. : -
L09'8%+ 0g = =«zsa* d+ 11 6l+ 26 ZOE SET+ 068'ZL+ 16 tLS*9EI+ 6L0'01+ $9 Coz ‘z+ ZLE‘9TL+ OIL @IE'O%Z*T+ 62L‘06+ 76 052 ‘691+ 60776 T+ TIT 601216 T+ 979 ' T+ ly 97S *€+ 099'62+ SL 942 °9S+ 760° L+ 79 «686 ‘91+ 91S *70E- % LIS ‘0C0't- T9z ‘St 09 «99S ‘41+ 09€ ‘Ee- 9% = LS9‘90I- 400'60I- et €08'Cez- 9710‘0%~ ez 064'CLeLe't- Be | Z90R'Y- 108 ‘4LI- WW sthetye $8z‘9z- T€ 000'29ize*9st- et €29"vle- 8S‘ Lst~ zt «ez yBE- 029‘ O0T+ 96 698 ‘61+ $9‘ Let- 6 wze*sss~ $Lo°el+ 86 «tz ‘S6I+ $L6+ "y = t10'%+ ' t 806+ €y 00°%+ 6£6'S6- 0% SS‘ 90z- Loy 9ETe ot «S68 AzE~ ote ‘8e- 6T TAZ OCz- 6€z'9- Se €zS‘*St- L197‘ 99%- 9 992°798- Ov 6+ 6S = 6L7"YI+ 179‘ L97- yt sos‘99edyo'yec t+ | ztt 99e'cee'z+ ise'9l- SZ OL LS YIT- '
—Tunowyy” pz ey Tjunouy—
wne101300 Gsdin08
epnas aog | AB20u0 [[e 204
+) SlWOdNI 80:
(+) Sa¥oaXa Nie LEN
y 30 1 eSeg
toe‘t 990' Lz
812 ‘66 90€ ‘40z 9£6'961 429‘ T01 $L0‘6%%'% £28 ‘OC zSL'44 c98‘¢ 889°612'Z 0
6c ett 659892 192 ove 18S ‘St: 128695 17s ‘¢8 860° LS Le ‘0S9 8L6'9T 66L' 942%
978 ‘ey 0
1e9°9Ee €62°9S4 at Lez 6L1°€9 9zz° Lett 0
911'00% ze9'129
996°OST
CRETE R TS CES GJ100xg PEEVES EES EBT Ea | e}uows oc dex ByAGdKg qaoday Sjuswaipnoes La [wq0L
Estee BS4 ‘Zl
062 '€£z 60S ‘L27z wz L19't 9726 ‘OSZ e1'99e'F 104‘ € 966 ‘OOT 7S$8‘0Z TLI‘68T'T 99591 zeL' Ut 98° ne wee" 61404 9S4‘9ST 12S ‘Iz $29‘78 e19'Soz £78‘ 961 4¢s‘689't
890‘ 62 Z10'%
400°%
Lz‘ ez 960 ‘221 €06'9
9s9°Le 097° Lz
6L2 ‘41
609°TE 96%'S00'€
91z'9€
"€ $90‘T
BLz‘S Syl's ezz‘9
cee'y 886 ‘89 064‘T 199'Z Let e216 0 esz'e evl'St 660‘'2Z S18*Z $86‘9€ 919'9 929'22 ece'9e ool 6S8'901
76°72 0
€9L' Lz 016 8z 79€°4% 87s ‘9 067°89 0
210°6 ezS°LT
619°9 ]
!
aqsoduy
ya
78 PANT TIGIO woarj equawertnbez NLd
786 ‘i Lee"9
U2 1118'S 6L0‘SY
0S9‘0t
S7z ‘Het $66‘T etZ's _too't
SIL'64 Std | OL
682°2'
ZLU'9T S92 , €co‘ot 1 6st't { 986°€ 958‘ Ft oes‘s ele '6L
' 0989 6%
88!
St ‘Ol 619'L 089) 206'€ €70‘9T cs
cee vec ‘8s
| ors't
S6z 4oc‘8
soe‘le 819121 6SS'19 0£L'6z Z10° 904 Ist ‘el est‘6l 648'T 649% 6"e't 0 te97'Ls e860 ESL'16 €26'02 829 '6SZ e98‘Ty 2470 ‘027 946 ‘ZC 4998'S TOL ‘Tle
OSt‘9z 0
10% OET 960 ‘O1Z ESt‘tt
£40‘ 069'20L
0
L€s‘69° e764
910'ZE
aqaodwy
—— eee
Veet GOES
Gua 48 €66°ZET z249'8C4
C6l'ze Lay hyz't es9'ot "4S ‘6E 698'6 6L1°669 90'S S99's Sz‘ El 995‘89 976°L1 €S$0‘02
11Z‘O1 oz1‘Ze
zee'o2t , 1,
569'99 gts‘z9s |
78 ‘9271 eZ
416
WL'ly Les ‘es Lore
€6z ‘02 Oco'19T
0z9°¢
ozo‘! 202° 704
Sey°e
peo
worz squawazznbaz Ald
|
"6 429'1
en's BIS‘L Tes zt
sss‘9
coe ‘zor S4S‘1 612% 91
elc’sé 0 10z's 94S ‘El
Lec‘zz SIZ €67'92 16S‘ 692‘07 LE1'6z soo‘t osy'Zet
eg't 0
OL TE cesi0s
688 ‘OT
' ej}Uows.u{ de. 8210dx
qao0dwy eS [eanjeu worz equowaaznbex Ld
(#nia_ 30 epussnoya ul)
z stqey
ele's Olt ‘Ol
Z9Z'EU 009'8 70S ‘06 96z ‘91 ZZ7€ ‘062 ze‘ cov's 896 $89'2y €9s 9%S ece't $80 ‘el 046‘ 70%'L 986 900'4 617 ‘ZI 9ec‘tt ost ‘Zel z97'6 ° sot
16
918'9 99%°9 zoe soe‘t 892 '6 186
642 08s ‘Ez
69‘
Tiisassu[ Tay Ji0dw] pus ejr0dxg “SN TSIOL JO SVT TOD VOTTTIN 4% ila u
928 a19‘St
8c9'0S Sz0'OL 929°9IT 40°19 TLL‘ UIS'T eee ‘yt 029‘02 zz9'
sor ‘Zod 0
6797'84 7547921 72S ‘807 Sze *6t 992‘9%% 1S4‘€€ 079° 61 966° TL? soe ‘6 60L'cez‘T
Loz‘ st 0
70%‘ 6ST €19'961 mL‘ 16
76€ ‘07 LSS ‘OC
(¢)
SEE ‘062 986'CLY
229° TOl
$8” 6" ZEL'06
ezs‘ezt 70108 866'2%8 9eL‘ IST o1z‘902'2 z£0' 9 oce ‘os 710'6 26S ‘L6E z9U‘S 6980'S B44 LT ery ‘Sot “gsc ‘et 4 $96'989 9916 ete ‘Ze z18 ‘EI s9z‘60t 710‘9%6
zze'ee $l6
806
$94°C9 92209 9718 '%
SST‘ZT Ov1'98
Ov1'6
IL‘ tz 1c8 ‘892 ‘2
S9s*9v
ejyUomsb[ dex #2100x
aguoduy
GNATOIjed opnad
weg 9 vuop aeardosd WT For puw Buy “Ov . “6t eraqty Dpamyrwds = “gE raqqna 2,394 WAS pues spepzszew Jyaseyy “LE eT eopways peanapnozsy Og eyonporad eoywayd “CE Buyauyad = “9 Busyustrand = “€€ pacoqiadeg ‘Z€ sjonpoad zadrqg “TE . aanzqzurny 19430 ‘OE BAN AzUANZ PLOYZENOH —° 67 #39npoad poom snoaue{] 205 pu pue poomstd pue xIOMIT TH °9Z sTTyu BSuzuvtd pue sppzunes “3upssoy °/z dyonpord at yaxad paaeozaqey snosuc{ [ISTH °97 yareddy °S7 spoo8 ayux pus Ar9~90H = ° 47 eBuzszAod 10073 pue Sazy3xa2 SnoauRT [220TH “CZ ST TI perry pue urek *eoz,1qezy Aorivu pue peorg °77 Buzangoeznuew od eQoL “17 sjonpoid poog °0% gouBsupl1o 19430 “61 SaT21yaa aoede pus sa{tsstm paping “gt \ ONLYNLOVANNYA : ‘ BOFIMAWsUOD YePIUePyeaquo’ APN “ET NOILONYLSNOD 1 Suyuyo AIZFTFIIZZ pues TeomwayD “IT Suzphaaenb pus Suzuzm Avyt> pue auois = "OT Suyuyo
aio -[eIaw snozzazuou 19410 °C BSuyuyw v1o 1addoQ “9 Suyuyw 930 uoil = “¢
: ONININ
sarzarae Ardy TF pues ‘h1389207 faangpnoysa8y °y sayaaysyzy pug 41969103 °E
sg onpoid peangtnayaBe asyyo pue edory °Z
' sg onpoid
DOWAATT PUB RIOISIATT = “T SAlUsNS1d GNV AULSAYOA “AMNLINITUV
spoy KULSHONI
a ee ene EER EEREne
SUEN
woz equowaiznbez Nid
GQUIWII TNs
Ph teste
6
z88- ue 9t0‘9T- S96 ‘B61 L16'zet s9s‘ot 2656 coetytt ave ‘00T 610°L 078 ‘99 86 'S9 gaourytdde prodauaont 79L Lea" cot ce 662‘ TIT+ o1's8 017 66l c6' 126 ‘ot c1e'8” 750° 901 196°C 016 ‘0€ L6C snavinddy . peyzazenpey proneneta "Se 960 ‘97+ ge cee ‘ttt+ tst'S9 069 ‘9Lt s79°€ 62L°6 assicc 86 "LB 199°L ane ‘Sz zys ‘te quoud prba vopINaysIsdP pus uozss pwunurzd ayrz99ta 9 waz‘ TOTt ZOT ZZ ‘SSz+ £02 ‘S97 S17‘ 00 zsy't oze"st | $9782 1sz'sst oss ‘zt 019 ‘St 968 ‘91T paupysrw KrISNPUF 9944295 "el Col 6+ es zse'tl+ Blt'ss 012899 088 ‘% 967 ‘€ 9L€ ‘6% 99$‘0€ 00z°€ $49 0% 908 ‘62 saupyyoun eozgyo 29420 pus exazzanodky °UL cos ‘171+ COT 756 VLt+ 6L0'9€T 1¢8'807 6716 oll‘ 076 ‘29 919‘z9t L6e ‘1% 08 ‘¢S Loc ‘66 quaudynba yoraysyz0d pur s2ajyndwog “TL 18 'Z+ 9S 082 ‘8+ 0 oec's 0 019 0 sz0°S soe 0 198 ‘% gaonpord doys autyorH = °0L 906 ‘99+ se ec7'estt 110‘0L2 687'227 gz7' at 666 ‘1% T9StISt Bc *2Zz ot g9z ct L€6‘€6 €78 ‘09 Aarauzyorm 1eF3228N Put yesousy «= °69 ‘ 1 876 ‘OTI+ OT 609'2L2 oot'z6z = 60 99S e19° ut 9s6'lz% ‘| 950209T %ZS “96% IL 16z‘€z 266°S0L 096 “91% Axouyyors Azasnpus peToeds 789 LOT TS+ 68 1¢2 ‘92 zoe'ayt = ce le 206 ‘8 c1r‘ot gis'te 4 69u77T ‘s eso‘tt Lze‘ts 766 ‘701 aousyoem Buyyzon TEI —*L9 CO LT+. cL oe TH+ goo’c9 , geet! tet ‘€ LLi's zzriuc «=: SELLS » | yoztz > .0L0%% €0S ‘0% 906 ‘LE + gueudpnba Buprpury Tet227H "99 986 ‘Iee+ BOT 656 ‘066+ 9co‘v 666° 7901 £86 ‘€ 069'SS got'oy 6BL*LTD qrez " ,es6*Le OLS ‘Tz ess ‘ese Axauzyors Paty TF0 - : H ' pue Buyusyu “yuopyoNnzysU08D °3$9 6529+ Oy 6IT‘2- 1e7'€zZ =—«--BOETIZTy, 1e7 ‘Ot get‘or. ‘| cec*out e9z ‘Tel t ard ‘l 11E'S9 oLt'te Axouyyoew wired = °%79 681 69+ 16 79L'88 est ‘v0 L16'982" 8129'S 262 ‘ST 694'6S gte'sst necte gcz‘ it coe st 2€0 ‘SOT g703e10U08 ‘ . pue sautqand ‘sauzdua °C9 298 02- tL 'tate eve'sss 966°2E%! oLs*8% S%L, 1% gaz'tye = 677°RN% 1zo’st "ec ‘St osetz9t ss tO‘ YT " saonpoad ' oy ; ; qeaau paaeazzqes 29420 °29 ety virt €6 Stc‘oyt+ | ty ‘9€T 6Z1 CBZ Lsz°9 12921 1z0'ze «=: We “ZT “eg |) 9998 een ve 198 ‘el saonpoad auzyoem m919S 719 6st 2S+ 66 2OL*YOet 991 '%6 0lv' 662 002°7 tz ‘el yee's9 «6 770% £07% 170° 1ee ‘22 Ole 9L yeasm p93n39n3 7s paaerz3zqed = °09 . ott ‘a+ e9 iee'9tr | €92'8 ays 19% 1e't €60°S geet 9ce't 768 °2 zou’ct gaanax}3 Butqontd 1 , pue sngviedde 3upieeH °6S ecy‘t- ge o9e*ct- , Lie ‘se 1S6‘02 00%‘T we * go6'cz = $t70‘ST 66% 4790'S 9494 gaauzequio> 1e22H 1 “8S cee ‘t+ 9¢ cor'6+ ° 0 €0%7'6 0 g7e | 0 t2z'7 x4] 0 ete '€ szonpord pram: \ snorrazuoU snoaut{ {229TH lees 979 ‘t+ Sy wze't+ 5 968 ‘64 gi3'ze8 e179 €07'9 costve ete “ve ole 790'% 961'SE 0z0‘8t Buynorp pue : BSuttto2 enozzajuou 19430 “9S og. ‘St+ 69 ves ‘9+ 166'y0tT = SLS* TIT 66S ‘TT gov'st | sez‘9n 9S “19 zis‘ 9929 sas‘z soc ‘8S Buzneap ! pue Buz {tos wnuywoty °$S 082 ‘ST ce TLE ty Ooms ‘Ls ect'st 419° 042 ‘tT oe 'yz 909 6692 9e4 LET ‘SZ us8°9 Buyncrp pue Buyt{o7 xaddog °%7S gy ‘Ovt- t 80'228~ 256 ‘806 90S ‘98 19's ert 'l GIL'9Ty 670 6E mp c6e°e aw‘91e «09 9E sno119juou : Kaepuoses put yrjaw : 1 snoarajuou Kaewzad 22420 “CS $80 ‘Sv+ 1g 9a *¢tI+ soc‘tze 260°6€7 susise | 46°89 186‘Zyt 069761 eye ‘ct 500 ‘6 gce’ezt =: TZO*LLT wauyunze Armwyid 72S gv ‘2e- 6% L16*L9- 109012 o6B*Zrl Sse‘ ¥t 186 °6 we're 6z7°es 6LL‘OT Lte‘l zoy‘oot =: £ ST “89 syeqau zaddo> Aarutid °1S * 1e0Ct+ 18 252 ‘28+ 6e2 ‘8 166°0CT 1e%7°% 269°9 | toe‘te cee’re ese‘t 978 709 ‘1 cco ‘Se sjonpoid ‘ : { gnoaur{{22ets pur Buy3103 . : (gazapunoz 19935 pue voll °0S 066 ‘Si¥" 2 9016959" gov'gae's zg9e‘cec*e ygziagt —-ez0°ee 418 ‘608"9 116 ‘0S8°% 090‘88 6L1'04 ecz‘oze «= 672 “LZ » ggonpord 19238 I . apeeq pue BaDeUIN, qysetd "69 $zz*ss~ ye wos{ctt~ 706°98% - OTC 69T a7 'st cyL's 196‘9tl = 726° 99 z02;‘st €L2°6 sesttyt oz ‘98 sqgonpord Key? . | pus auo 3s snoouey {aos tH “Ov Syl '8t- tt zyotee- Lez ‘et 64% ‘68 078 ‘Ss 9c0'¢ see‘6tt 0£6°6S 17s‘ ns 't 112 969 °€% ' saonpoad ‘ ! eaaazsuo> SAE? ‘quamaa LY Lty'tt- ze 00599" 990 ‘99T 99S‘ 6tl 886 ‘6 688°9 rertes 198 6€ 67'6 | 680°L 9S47°88 62z0'99 sse1o “99 i 19TO2T- Lt 892 ‘Z8Z- gor ‘zie ge ‘62 946 61 6se‘Tl oeniayt — s62'Cl we yt cor’ cel zz ‘et szonpoid 2243709T { , : pue 4v9Mjo003 *zay2e7T «SY ‘ B19 °06- 1z 9Sc‘vet~ Ley “Lte 6ze'z7t 96‘ LU 076 °L e9e'vIt 7670S 606 ‘21 Li's 6LL°991 191 ‘92 ; saonpoid ayasetd = °97 : £29'TL~ Zz 166 '69T- Evs‘Oze =—s-zSS*EST: e9e ot seo'e tl6‘zvt = c€0°S9 seg‘st gea'e yea'syt —- 400°C ! saonpord zeqana “C4 boos *eIs' Cle “z71'St- “124! “6yz' ‘ ‘ . ‘ aa at ans nent 97't 20‘ 992‘°S% gss‘ere tt sQonpor wnator39d 707 ove’ vis‘ et 1 g9t*zet’st Stettay'et 179° 6% er | ret’oe 16L'0? coetage © SLB" LET ma { (panuy3vo2) sR SvEnVR . seg — “Taanonvy squed —jyinowv gyasasse[ ass” CIs00ra giusussutder 93200% eer SEC LS squsasse{aas es700Ks sqasussepaea wTs00s SON spod wnajto13ed waIIN0s . * gaodul qaodwl qaodul qaodw] qaodw] . epnzo 303 KBx9u29 118 10a Sjuswaipnoes Tita =sGoDanoe A9YIO ywoo . cee [eanqeu gnajoised Spnay _ ——— Fit na NI ———
wo2s sjuawaazznber ld wo1j equawesznbes Ald
=) Siuodnl YO yeroL woas'squoweaynbaa nia | wos3 equowas pnbo2 nia
(+) SL¥0dxX4 nia Lan
puesnoyd uy) fl teacL 3°
. iy yo % O8ed z 8Tq¥L
cma
wS$8 ‘07+ Wl 66 L 0% (1) 661‘07 0 69S'" ees*zt | 0 6tz'z 0 76802 squawannar 290 TET gti‘ cet 6L WS 7° L9F 0 9S7°l9 tr) 950°9 (ZL 9% 0 sss*e 0 9IL'ce goanqoyd voptoH “OTT dy Wy «689 0 689 0 €4 et 0 Ss? 0 ty ayedaa ayyqouo ny STL Liz*ez+ te €87‘OS+ (\) €ev‘os te) 4ts's ° coetet 0 6z0°¢ 0 L1Z°8% BadyAIAB pouoysaojoad svoaurt {ast “YT gec'st ° us ‘7a T* Ut 0 “etttt 0 z08 0 70959 0 08s 0 g6c'S Buzapazaapy “CTT C16‘ CI+ 99 cee’ lz+ () cee lz 0 876 °2 0 6L7°6 0 469°1 0 CIGEL Ba9TAIB GBaUTENT snoauvtpIaeTH “ZT LL" 6+ 19 7S6°9T+ 0 Z56°91 (\) c6r‘t 0 992°S 0 Lt0't 0 Lt0'6 gaopaaas pouosizad 39430 “TTT sey‘oet 06 szo*Cett 0 6z9 ‘Cel 0 L00‘2t 0 9nS'*ze 0 sco‘s o . sc7‘08 saovtd Buy8por pur earn “Out . Sa 1 Auas 660‘ 1CZ+ got coe‘ 7stt 0 £98‘ 9Se 0 L7z°ST 0 9z2°C8 119‘ 0 660‘ 1€2 aaeges [waa 29430 *60t 98z ‘rt SS CEE Gt. use 06L‘9T sto’t sez‘ 159° 696°S 878 4en'e gol'l aoueansul = "LOT 96c' i+ 97 167° EF 0 167e | 0 6c ; 0 905‘1 ' ost 0 9ec't aoucuya "901 } ' ; GLvisa iva ONV AONVWISNT SONVNLa ‘ t ’ . . C1toe+ te ote’ 79+ 0 . oce'9. () wee =f 0 109 t% eez‘e 0 C1t ‘oe apeaa TFeI9U “SOT 979 '92+ ze 60707 0 607‘0%, 0 ' 617 °% 0 90L4°8 6se°% ti) 92992 aperz azesajoun "70T - ’ ! 1 ' FovuL “WVisd UNV FIVSAIOUM t \ | 69 7 t+ zs gst‘ 0 este 0 08s 0 40°97 $9z 0 6997°% eopazas Kseayurs puc 293em “COT Suet & 19 «908 Bz+ one uit 0S$ ‘ov ZL2°S9 rs1°9l gzit eet z10‘ 1% 99% 199° ost ‘oz 6276 °2Z sapattsan 9Fs290Ta =“ 10T 0857+ 6” sov'st 0 sov's. 0 "9 0 998°T LLz 0 08s‘Z Buyacesproaq AL pur oppru “O0T $76" 7 cs 09S "8+ €S2°S7 €1e ‘es oto" 90S°S g19tt cag‘et goo'z * Leet’ Blt‘ 9% €80 ‘Te AL pue oFper j i qdaoxa “suozaeozunuwoyd "66 sie‘ ect+ WU Lz‘ 7ez+ 0 €L2* 92 0 07S ‘21 0 890. 6% 0 0s9‘et 0 siefcet vopjurzodsursa 19410 °86 . 617’ C66r got 786 eet T+ 19E ‘029 tye '709'T 9se's 077‘ 02 946 9% 797 ‘C6 990 °Le 61S‘ 79T coL*zse WOME vozaeziodsurz2 ItV 16 eu 7 1s 6cetor zyt'7es*t Ter'ols*t Lee‘zs evs 'zS ZEL*SBe G6z ‘Let et‘ 60t 919601 66R°9T0'T 0Z0‘TZ0°T vopaeazodswesy 2928H °96 Lis‘ ol+ ze 609 *eBt: 0 609 ‘8a 0 oot'z . 0 2720'S 609° 0 cus‘ol vuopieaszodsues) Anal °S6 126'98+ ge «9 s9*SzIt 779 ‘et ect‘ at cc? eze‘e €96‘C Lty*o€ 660 ‘1 gcc‘ot Lz0‘et 966‘ 66 voz aezsodsuesy prort ted "C6 766°9%%- 8 618‘°909- L61'006 BLE‘ C6Z ovs ‘69 19S°ST 19L'8t7 Oty 621 506‘0% gat‘ rt 110‘ 18€ 610‘ CT s3onpoad + t porngorjnucw snoouv {Taos Th "t6 Lie‘ lz g 980°CGt 499‘oet SSL*C2z z6S‘S suy'6 LS4‘S9 tye tot oel‘s 416 ‘ot ece‘es sso‘ tot ‘ saytddns : pue quoudynba opydraso od “16 G6t'ST- oc =761°79- 419‘ TO ozo le ocs'9 oA on 4 e989 ‘S? L66° Ct Olly 690'2 otha Scz°6t quaudynba syupsyado pue Trrt3do °06 20L‘°8z+ ee 1se°9o+ 661°SZ 97668 sez‘t ec’? 2e6°tt 9se°t? 29 ero? 1968 cog'eg | sauaUMAIsUT TeIUOP pur Te°7PH "6B eee’ art ep zee" 6et C16" TET $99 ‘12 1zL‘8 116°C ste‘t9 £92 ‘66 Seis: 07S ‘ot £09 ‘ES 166°L6 gquoumaqsuy Buy{{o2IU0? . pus DEgTIUITOS «peuopssajzord *98 eee’ d+ 9 988*Oz+ corre 6L0'82 zu! ett ¢0z ‘9 qte'st Sz oot't 796 °% Lz ‘ot jan ‘quaudynbe vopaeziodsuraL “18 687 ‘16- st s60*srt- oga'nty «= S9.L°9L gestat ‘zee 800‘ 182 192° 67 Sotzt gnt'z ett «—«- ZC“ TZ quand ynba ° : : voy eqiodsuray snoou . ‘ | \ eey [aoe Fe 29yI0 PUL proapzeu 98 009° l+ 7 = v9 17+ ZES*EZ 9LI'SY 1t¢e*t ely'z Liye 00L'92 Ls 1ss*t avo l L767 ayedax . ‘ : pue BupPTEMa aod pue ays °S8 Lea’ t6tt Lot ose*ccet -MCG7It BZ“ 766 als ! Bol te eez ‘1s z06'1E7 outs Lec Ly 07869 Loz‘ 177 ayeaoayy °%8 9L1°S09° ¢ G0COTL'Z- 971 '086'C ace‘6oa ‘t He1°96t Sz ‘16 697°0S7°% BLTStt't 692 ‘621 etc’ 79 992'70Z'T 980665 sapayyaa 3030H = *CB Zet'St 6e 6 SS9°E oorgtt ~— szc‘ett cec'e 9¢9°9 602 ‘6S %LS‘0S ez8'9 mac's 696'%7 1s1‘0S Aaauyyora . 1 peogaqeT? snooury{ 228 TA “78 ; 69S'SOTt oot ozo‘oczt 6eL‘ 66 s09 ‘627 oct ‘vt 0C6' 62 786'06 667° SBT 6S1'6 €67'0% ytc’se ¢98‘06t gquauoduos 2720239912 "18 Cut‘ 6t+ 94 6SE*t9F 9L7'8S sce ‘out 6129 77's 6S1'92 16'1S mee't 9798'S Le ‘Sz L19°%S quowd nba : wo z72979p Pue Buypeusys } | . . *Bupaapusueza AL oFped “08 { UE Pet ey 1¢0'S+ Wet 20262 o0L0'} ose‘t £206 107° Tt 999 9ce £6t'9 ste's snjeardde 1 \ . ; ydes8aqtaa pur auoydeTaL °6L 0z9‘1t?- S We Le6- asetgto't 96°88 tso's9 TL7'S mister” ott PLE 89°87 969°4 weon'esy = eee‘ t9 wyae Jupayeoes AL Puw omped ‘el * . 978’ 6° me CLL“ OE SCL*EST 796°7ET 9ze'l -992°9 1zS‘18 Uz ‘9 ziz'd sst'9 SLt°L9 Lze'es Supata pus Bupaystt 24220013 “tl ‘ ' (panuyauos) ORTUNTOVINNW : eee : : - — ee SOD Hl Tunowy ) syucy qunowy gyuowesc{dor BaA00xXa syuswea0{ de. Bi10dxd eQuU0wWI BL vl $3100xa gyUIWIIET SPY SyiodKg gguowIIeT a1 8310 Ma, | WEN pod | wnojo1300 Baoanos. qaoduy qaodw] gaoduy qioduy * qaodwy epnio 104 ABaau2 11s 1204 SjusaoA nde Ta 718923008 aay Qo yaoo Ges peanqeu una {ora00 apnaz Rursnagant >) Siu0dKT YO yeaoL “ wolrz equawarznbe2 Hla woz ejuawaiznbes Ald wo1z gquowarznbe1 Ald wo2j sjuoweaznbea NL (+) 6280dxa ALG LAN . , (snLa 3° spucsnoy: a ae s3a0dx v ° . .
y 30 € O8ed z eTqeL
eqzodxa pul 921008}
+qxaa 942 ut yoy aeuet sx? 22s 3992n0s
4 o o3x0d%e ov e2an 91942 yotue 203 gacsey? Kaqenput 270N
i *guppuno2 3° aenwooq 610303; 03 ppe 20U keo 178906 *atqe2 943 wory prazteo gay 8320d0F pazayaedwo> a
| gooayp 29042 3° quequos nid 243 gees peangeu Pus
' , ezanod powr24))
\ ' ‘ sayqea 243 jo Mort yout -03-3%24 aya Ut unoys St
te «1809 ¢yno10238d epna> 3° gjaodxa pul 932ddut 30934P sapny ox? guzp{ued +gg20duy 390 yo 20p10 Buz puereeP UL 17 1
a8 pus tzanod 2v2TONU ¢yanodoaphy 929 9994N08 23420, at
z00'S6T'S8~ ySe' ore 78 9nS'96L't cen’ ees 't Est’ 6Ls‘02 621" 6S "8? 19‘ L00' tz 6gt'006"” gus eae’ 7th an TEL 62 avioL 066'807' 7L- 979 cLe'ot goz*nze't tye 'ose’ ve sz ts ees peanaeu pus #1909 syn aqo232d apna? 5° 9310dx9 pue 92100ut 30901TP jo qua quo> £31903 . qto'9ee*ot~ ecz'eto'st i9etesz|? €96'SL0°C go Ler’ 6t 762159 ‘8% seB peanaes ‘ pus ‘180? éqmapor204 apni> Ut opera 4oo2tP Quzppntox? #1 #203995 + gge*s6t~ ot 080 ezS~ 090 *€zS 694" S6E 0 92378 pue wes on ouye7293ve ¢yanes) geauysnd *gz1 . i] SIMLSNGNt WANG sz‘ ott sot zug tle 0 TLE‘ TLE 0 100°" 0 cg LS ' ge60‘t 0 szz‘ot g99f1d192U9? peaopad 22420 “921 cos’ ot os teat 0 ot’9 0 Lez 0 uco't o |! €87 0 os‘? aaqg3o 280d "220 ' ‘| ; | ERTL EME! TNwiNWaA0d : ‘ ' eLs‘9tt or coc‘ett 0 coc’ 6t 0 "9° 0 gic‘9t ) 6Le‘t ) cLs*9ot gaopazes qeuosaeonPa ort gost zy $80° TF ° seo:t 0 on =! 0 zee 0 $s 0 80S paazares TOTP ' 30430 pus #46 72U9P «3032000 “tl | (panuzawo?) TaAAwaS qesrsTess TOOT Serer 5, ST10NKS ee eee —_—_— cl —— pod
‘anayorzad
apnso 304 =} SLuOdWI 40
() g1uoaxa Ne Lan
r( jonowv ) yuey qunowy
rEYPOC
faxouo 11¥ 304
: RursaA an
y20duT poo?
wor gaguaweapabes ne
Teangeu :
— FEY UCL 2ayIO wor gquanaapnbes AL
1 g3ucweayndo2 nua
wors pquawerzabes nla
pugenoy? ul) Th pea0L 3°
939% aseg
Cite this document
Federal Reserve (1974, July 31). The Energy Content of U.S. Exports and Imports. Ifdp, Federal Reserve. https://whenthefedspeaks.com/doc/ifdp_1974-51
@misc{wtfs_ifdp_1974_51,
author = {Federal Reserve},
title = {The Energy Content of U.S. Exports and Imports},
year = {1974},
month = {Jul},
howpublished = {Ifdp, Federal Reserve},
url = {https://whenthefedspeaks.com/doc/ifdp_1974-51},
note = {Retrieved via When the Fed Speaks corpus}
}